The best phishing simulation tool is the one that fits your size, budget, email environment and language needs. We compare eight platforms (KnowBe4, Hoxhunt, Proofpoint ZenGuide, Microsoft Attack Simulation Training, Cofense PhishMe, GoPhish, Phished and PhishTop) so you can shortlist in minutes.
In This Guide
What Are Phishing Simulation Tools?
The 8 Tools: KnowBe4, Hoxhunt, Proofpoint ZenGuide, Microsoft, Cofense, GoPhish, Phished, PhishTop
Tools Compared
How to Choose: 8 Factors
Features Worth Looking For
How Much Do They Cost?
6 Mistakes When Choosing
FAQ, Bottom Line and Keep Reading

Quick pick: Large awareness program → KnowBe4. Adaptive, gamified learning → Hoxhunt. Threat-informed, Proofpoint stack → ZenGuide. Already on eligible Microsoft 365 → Attack Simulation Training. Technical team, no license budget → GoPhish. Bangladesh-focused, Bangla and English lures → PhishTop.
Disclosure: PhishTop is built by Penough, the publisher of this guide. We list it alongside other tools; this is a curated starting list, not a definitive ranking.
What Are Phishing Simulation Tools?
A phishing simulation platform lets you create, send and monitor controlled phishing exercises. Depending on the tool, it tracks whether employees open the email, click a simulated link, interact with an attachment, submit data on a controlled training page, report the message, and complete follow-up training. Modern platforms add automated scheduling, department targeting, role-specific scenarios, risk scoring and instant feedback.
The goal is not to trick people. It is to build awareness through controlled practice. New to the concept? Start with What Is Phishing Simulation?
5 Reasons Businesses Buy One
Find awareness gaps: Training completion is not the same as spotting a real lure.
Improve reporting: Measure whether people use the official reporting channel.
Target training: Finance sees payment fraud, HR sees fake CVs; department targeting makes drills relevant.
Show progress: Compare click rate, report rate, phish-prone percentage, repeat interactions, training completion and risk trends across campaigns.
Cut manual work: Replace spreadsheets and hand-built templates with centralized scheduling, tracking and reporting.
The 8 Tools
This is a curated list to evaluate, not a ranking. The right choice depends on size, budget, existing security infrastructure, training needs and in-house technical skill. Always confirm current features and pricing with each vendor.
1. KnowBe4
Best for: A broad security-awareness and simulation program. Product page
Key capabilities: Phishing and vishing simulations, training content, automated campaigns, AI-assisted personalization, employee risk scoring, real-time coaching, reporting and analytics, and a Phish Alert Button for reporting.
Why consider it: Larger workforces or established programs benefit from broad content and campaign management.
Check before buying: Features by subscription tier, content fit, email and identity integrations, licensing and minimum user counts, and whether advanced reporting needs a higher tier.
2. Hoxhunt
Best for: Adaptive, personalized, gamified training. Website
Key capabilities: Adaptive simulations, AI-supported personalization, gamified micro-training, role-based learning paths, behavioral reporting and multichannel social-engineering simulations.
Why consider it: The adaptive approach may help teams that want higher participation and continuous learning.
Check before buying: Simulation channels, language support, customization, integrations, reporting, cost and implementation effort.
3. Proofpoint ZenGuide
Best for: Threat-informed awareness. Phishing simulation page
Key capabilities: Threat-informed simulations, awareness training, employee reporting, targeted follow-up training, behavioral analytics and risk-based learning.
Why consider it: Ties exercises to real-world threat information, and may suit organizations already using Proofpoint email security.
Check before buying: Integration with existing Proofpoint products, feature availability, localization, reporting needs and total cost.
4. Microsoft Defender for Office 365: Attack Simulation Training
Best for: Organizations on eligible Microsoft 365 plans. Microsoft Learn
Key capabilities: Simulated phishing campaigns, built-in and custom payloads, credential-harvest and malware-attachment scenarios, QR code options, targeted users, training assignments and reports.
Why consider it: Uses a capability you may already own and ties into your Microsoft security stack.
Licensing note: Microsoft's documentation names Defender for Office 365 Plan 2 (add-on or included in subscriptions such as Microsoft 365 E5) for the full experience. Verify your entitlement before planning.
Check before buying: Current licensing, admin permissions, reporting and whether built-in training covers your wider awareness needs.
5. Cofense PhishMe
Best for: Phishing resilience and reporting behavior. Website
Key capabilities: Simulated campaigns, realistic scenarios, awareness exercises, educational feedback, campaign reporting, and professional or managed-campaign support options. Cofense also offers phishing reporting and response capabilities across its wider product set.
Why consider it: Suits teams wanting to link awareness drills to reporting and response processes.
Check before buying: The specific PhishMe package, training and reporting features, tool integrations, managed-service needs and pricing.
6. GoPhish (Open Source)
Best for: Technical teams wanting an open-source framework. GitHub
Key capabilities: Campaign creation and management, template customization, landing pages, recipient management, scheduling, result tracking, reporting and export, and an API.
Why consider it: Full control and no license fee for teams with in-house expertise.
Limitations: It is not a complete awareness-training platform. You manage hosting, mail-delivery infrastructure, security and maintenance, training content, follow-up and long-term program management. Free software still costs staff time. Use it only for authorized simulations within a defined scope.
7. Phished
Best for: Automated phishing awareness and behavioral training. Website
Capabilities to evaluate: Automated simulations, training modules, a Behavioral Risk Score, campaign management, progress tracking, reporting and analytics, and API options for integrating recipients, simulations and reporting into other workflows.
Why consider it: Appeals to teams that want recurring awareness activity on autopilot and behavior tracking over time.
Check before buying: Supported channels, training library and languages, automation depth, integrations, reporting, and subscription scope and price.
8. PhishTop by Penough
Best for: Businesses wanting localized simulation and awareness, especially in Bangladesh. PhishTop
Key capabilities: Localized Bangla and English phishing scenarios built around Bangladeshi business contexts; department and role segmentation; teachable-moment and micro-training; one-click reporting; human-risk scoring; compliance-ready report exports; branch-wise import.
Why consider it: Generic international templates can feel unfamiliar. Local scenarios (HR circulars, bank notices, courier updates, payroll requests) can make drills more realistic.
Check before buying: Campaign needs and templates, onboarding and segmentation, reporting and export, email-environment compatibility, data handling and privacy controls, deployment and support.
Phishing Simulation Tools Compared
Tool | Best Suited For | Main Strength |
|---|---|---|
KnowBe4 | Large awareness programs | Broad training and simulation ecosystem |
Hoxhunt | Adaptive employee learning | Personalized, gamified training |
Proofpoint ZenGuide | Threat-informed awareness | Threat-based simulations, risk insights |
Microsoft Attack Simulation Training | Microsoft 365 environments | Built-in Microsoft security integration |
Cofense PhishMe | Phishing resilience programs | Employee recognition and reporting |
GoPhish | Technical teams | Open-source flexibility |
Phished | Automated awareness programs | Behavioral insights, training automation |
PhishTop | Bangladesh-focused organizations | Localized Bangla and English simulations |
Use this as a starting point, not a performance ranking.
How to Choose: 8 Factors
Factor | Ask |
|---|---|
1. Requirements | Occasional tests, or continuous campaigns? Reporting, auto-training, risk scoring, compliance evidence, multichannel? |
2. Simulation capability | Customizable templates, attachment and link scenarios, QR code exercises, role targeting, safe landing pages. Relevance beats template count. |
3. Training features | Immediate feedback, short modules, role-based paths, auto-assignment, assessments, completion tracking. |
4. Reporting | Click rate, report rate, PPP, repeat interactions, department performance, completion, risk trends, exportable reports. |
5. Automation | Scheduling, recipient selection, training assignment, reminders, reports. Buy what you need, not every feature. |
6. Integrations | Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, email infrastructure, identity providers, HR directories, LMS, SIEM; plus allow-listing and delivery setup. |
7. Security and privacy | Data collection, storage and retention, access, encryption, export and deletion, regional rules. Never collect real passwords. |
8. Total cost | Subscription, per-user price, implementation, hosting and maintenance, content, support, admin time. |
Features Worth Looking For in a Modern Platform
Multichannel simulation: Email plus SMS, QR codes, voice and messaging, chosen according to your real risk.
AI-assisted personalization: Useful, but review generated content for accuracy, appropriateness and safety.
Immediate educational feedback: Teach at the moment of interaction.
Human-risk analytics: Combine clicks, reports, completion and repeats to coach, not punish.
Integration with security operations: Connect reported messages to your investigation and response workflow.
How Much Do They Cost?
No single price exists. Models include per-user pricing, annual subscriptions, tiered plans, custom enterprise quotes and open source (free licence, but hosting and upkeep cost time). Some vendors publish prices; many want a consultation. Microsoft's tool depends on eligible licensing. Compare total cost of ownership, and request a quote for your actual headcount and feature list.
6 Mistakes When Choosing
Choosing on price alone.
Focusing only on click rates.
Ignoring local language and business context.
Overlooking integration requirements.
Treating simulations as punishment.
Ignoring privacy and data protection before launch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which phishing simulation tool is best?
There is no single best. Shortlist from KnowBe4, Hoxhunt, Proofpoint ZenGuide, Microsoft Attack Simulation Training, Cofense PhishMe, GoPhish, Phished and PhishTop based on size, budget, integrations, training needs and language.
Are they safe?
Yes, when authorized and properly configured: controlled landing pages, approved scope, no real credential collection.
Are there free tools?
GoPhish is open source. Some vendors offer trials. Free software still needs hosting, maintenance and technical time.
Simulation software vs. awareness training software?
Simulation tools run and track fake phishing campaigns; awareness platforms add learning content and assessment. Many now combine both.
Can Microsoft 365 users simulate phishing?
Yes, through Attack Simulation Training with eligible Defender for Office 365 licensing. Check your plan.
Can tools test QR code phishing?
Some can. Microsoft documents QR code simulation options; verify exact capabilities of any platform you choose.
Bottom Line
The best platform is not the one with the most features. It is the one that helps your organization turn simulations into measurable improvements in employee behavior. Shortlist two or three, run a pilot with a small authorized group, and judge them on reporting quality and how people respond to the training.
Looking to strengthen phishing awareness? Explore PhishTop by Penough.
Keep Reading
Guide | Why |
|---|---|
The pillar overview | |
How simulation works | |
First campaign playbook | |
How to Build an Effective Security Awareness Training Program | The surrounding program |
References: KnowBe4 · Hoxhunt · Proofpoint · Microsoft Learn · Cofense · GoPhish · Phished · PhishTop